A Response to “Talking About God”

(I met my friend Seth Jones during our freshman year of college, and we remain good friends to this day. He now lives across the country from me in Maine where he is a pastor. Below is his thoughtful and passionate response to yesterday’s essay “Talking About God.” I am posting his email in its entirety with his permission.)

Dear Melissa:

I read your new posting in your blog. There is a lot I liked and appreciated about it. The fear of talking about God is misplaced, and we would all be better served if we could learn to listen and speak respectfully and with reflection regarding those most important things in our lives.

When I was in Maine for about four months the AA group started meeting in the basement of the church. I was thrilled to have them there; they had to leave the place they were meeting until a construction project finished. Some of the people in the AA group, though, had problems with being in a church. Sometimes, they had to meet in the sanctuary and they felt–threatened?–by the large blue stained glass cross that is in the front of the sanctuary. So they moved.

Before they moved, I went to one of their meetings. After the meeting, I swear to God, five people came up to me to explain their belief system or why they didn’t go to church. I guess pastors inspire that kind of thing; I have begun to perceive it as a kind of confession. They all began the same way: “I am spiritual but not religious.” By the fourth person, I started responding, “That is OK, I am religious but not in the least bit spiritual.” One took offense and the other said that was impossible.

All of them had a bizarre and distorted view of what constituted “organized religion.” I don’t know what “organized religion” is. It can’t be dogma, because everyone I have met who does not have a religion has a dogma of some sort. The meaning of the word “religion” has as its root word the same root word as the word “ligament.” So “religion” means “to re-join, re-connect.” Whenever I am in public and someone talks about organized religion, I always ask what they mean. They tell me, and then I say, “Yeah, I don’t believe in that either.” Because I really don’t. Because it is not what I am involved in either. Most say, “Churches tell you what to do and what to believe. It is all about rules.” They have no clue how offensive it sounds to someone who has devoted their lives to the experience of worship, community, and spiritual growth.

My biggest problem and the biggest personality difficulty I have is that I ask questions of people. When they say, “I am spiritual but not religious,” I ask questions. It drives people crazy because I keep asking questions. “Where did you learn that perspective?” “Which wars were religious wars in your mind and in your understanding?” “When you say ‘Christianity’, what kind of ‘Christianity’ do you mean?” “You just used the word ‘puritanical.’ Do you know anything about the Puritans? They might surprise you. Did you know they were the first sexual revolutionaries?” “You say nature is your church. What does that mean? How is God present for you when nature kills and destroys without discrimination?”

I can be exceptionally annoying. Worse, I actually know a thing or two about other religious systems as well.

My suggestion is not to take religion out of the discussion, but talk through, with, and beside it. It is integral to how we all understand God, whether we have rejected or accepted a particular religious perspective. You would not have a spiritual perspective if it weren’t for some community defining their experience together regarding their relationship with God. My daughter’s school doesn’t allow religious expression of any kind–no crosses, no Stars of David, no head coverings. It is such a tragic loss of opportunity. The open free discussion among one another about faith, religion, spirituality, and non-belief can only be invigorating and helpful. I guess what I am saying is that I will not give up my “religion” to talk about my relationship with God. My religion is how I am in relationship with God.

I don’t mean to sound harsh–your very well-written article got me going. That is a good thing.


About flyingnotscreaming

My weekly quotes and "Notes from Flights" are my attempt to learn how to soar through life's unknowns with grace and gratitude. Thank you for flying with me. --Melissa Myers Place, writer, reader, massage therapist, mother, wife, and daughter
This entry was posted in Essays and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to A Response to “Talking About God”

  1. Mary Hirsch says:

    Melissa, I appreciate Seth’s thoughtful comments in response to your “Talking About God” essay. And, he’s spot on when he says, “we would all be better served if we could learn to listen and speak respectfully and with reflection regarding those most important things in our lives.” It’s an American thing, I think, we aren’t thoughtful listeners these days on any subject. I question whether we’re even deep-thinkers anymore. As you know, I am an “organized religion” woman. Most of my small-town Iowa happy memories, growing up, revolve around church-related activities and social encounters. (Those Methodists made the best pies at the Summer ice cream socials!) I thought it important that You grew up with the Sunday School experiences, the choirs and Summer Bible Schools. Try as I might, I’ve never found a church home since moving to Nevada eight years ago. I’ve missed it. That’s why I am especially glad to now be moving back to Colorado and my Episcopalian church home. Because your stepfather was Jewish, we, as a family, embraced it all, even if some of his faith rejected us. There is much in all “religions” to question, even to abhor. But, just like in politics, I feel more inner strength by hanging my hat on the organized peg, working from within, whether it be as a Christian or a Democrat.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s